2012 Top 50 Prospects

Below is a list of the top 50 prospects in baseball, in my opinion.  The ranking, player name, position, team, date of birth and highest level in 2011 are listed on the top line, followed by their Minor League stats for 2011 below.  The top 20 prospects have a little bit more information there, again it is my opinion of the player.  I am not a scout, I am a school teacher and father.  I read a lot of baseball and research on my own.  Leave comments about anyone you feel that I left out or under sold, I’d love to mock you for being wrong!

Top Prospects 2012

1.      Bryce Harper, OF, Washington: 10/16/92, Double-A

.297/.392/.501, 24 2B, 17 HR, 87/59 K/BB, 26 SB

Harper is as elite as it gets.  He could start the year in the Washington outfield.  His power is off the charts and he is about as can’t-miss as it gets.

2.      Matt Moore, LHP, Tampa Bay: 6/18/1989, Majors

12-3, 1.92 ERA, 155 IP, 210/46 K/BB, .184 BAA

Moore was a part of the Rays Postseason roster and he’ll be a part of their Opening Day roster in 2012.  He’s better than David Price ever was, so consider him a future ace.

3.      Shelby Miller, RHP, St. Louis: 10/10/90, Double-A

11-6, 2.77 ERA, 139 2/3 IP, 170/53 K/BB, .219 BAA

Miller is a studly prospect in a solid organization.  He can throw strikes and he is an ace in the making.  He could be ready by mid-2012, but the Cards won’t need him unless Wainwright’s elbow isn’t all the way back, Lohse comes back to reality, or Westbrook falters.

4.      Julio Teheran, RHP, Atlanta: 1/27/91, Majors

15-3, 2.55 ERA, 144 2/3 IP, 122/48 K/BB, .232 BAA

His Triple-A stats don’t blow you away, but Teheran was just 20 when he was facing the vets and advanced hitters there.  He may not have struck out 10 per 9 IP, but he did well for his age.  His fastball and change are great pitches, but he still could refine his breaking ball.  If Teheran improves his curve, he could be better than any pitcher on this list.

5.      Jesus Montero, C/DH, Seattle:11/28/89, Majors

.288/.348/.467, 19 2B, 18 HR, 98/36 K/BB

Montero was just traded to Seattle, the hitter’s wasteland of the American League.  While his fantasy production could take a hit there, he is still a player with elite upside.  Montero is a DH that has caught before.  He could get enough starts there to keep catching eligibility in fantasy leagues, but he could be the 2nd Mariners DH to make the Hall of Fame…Edgar Martinez is my plug here.

6.      Jurickson Profar, SS, Texas: 2/20/93, Low-A

.286/.390/.493, 37 2B, 8 3B, 12 HR, 63/65 K/BB, 23 SB

Profar could be the 2B of the future in Texas if Elvis Andrus sticks around.  The fact that he was 18 and showing the patience and hitting skills in full-season ball makes scouts and fans drool.  His body doesn’t ooze the ability to be a power hitter in the future, but you have to wonder if some of those 37 2B will make it out of Arlington.  Alfonso Soriano wasn’t a beefy power hitter, either.

7.      Manny Machado, SS, Baltimore: 7/6/1992, High-A

.257/.335/.421, 20 2B, 5 3B, 11 HR, 73/45 K/BB, 11 SB

The comparisons to ARod coming out of High School weren’t just due to his size.  This is a future All-Star SS with power and speed.  Machado IS the future of the Baltimore organization.  If he doesn’t become the star that he looks like he could, the current 14-season long losing streak will become 20.

8.      Devin Mesoraco, C, Cincinnati: 6/19/88, Majors

.289/.371/.484, 36 2B, 15 HR, 83/52 K/BB

Mesoraco looked like a flop of a first-round pick in 2009.  Then…2010 happened and 2011 legitimized his status as a future All-Star catcher.  By dealing Yasmani Grandal to San Diego and letting Ramon Hernandez leave via Free Agency, Cincinnati is committing to Mesoraco as their catcher right now.  He’ll split time with Ryan Hanigan, but could become a 20-25 HR hitter as soon as this season.

9.      Trevor Bauer, RHP, Arizona: 1/17/91, Double-A

1-2, 5.96 ERA, 25 2/3 IP, 43/12 K/BB, .257 BAA

Bauer didn’t have an impressive ERA, but 43 punch outs in 25 2/3 IP is just sexy.  Bauer looked better than his UCLA teammate, Gerrit Cole, in his final season there, enough to make me think that he is going to be better long-term.  He’s small, like Tim Lincecum (but not that small), but he possesses top of the rotation stuff.

10.  Jacob Turner, RHP, Detroit: 5/21/1991, Majors

4-5, 3.44 ERA, 131 IP, 110/35 K/BB, .238 BAA

Turner could be an ace or he could be the next Rick Porcello, a young starter with great stuff who was rushed to the Majors, losing his breaking ball while looking to throw strikes in the Minors.  Turner’s name keeps coming up in trade rumors, specifically for Matt Garza, but the Tigers may have a better arm here long-term.  They just need to be a little careful with him.

11.  Anthony Rendon, 3B, Washington: 6/6/90, NONE

Rendon was the top college bat in the 2011 MLB Draft.  He could be an All-Star at 3B, but he’ll move to 2B if Ryan Zimmerman is going to stick around in Washington.  At 2B, if he posts numbers like he is projected to, he could become a Hall of Fame talent.  He has enough athletic ability to hold down the position, even after the ankle injury.

12.  Martin Perez, LHP, Texas: 4/4/91, Triple-A

8-6, 4.33 ERA, 137 1/3 IP, 120/56 K/BB, .284 BAA

Perez, like Teheran, was 20 last season while pitching in Triple-A.  He may have posted underwhelming statistics, but he still has a great repertoire, one that makes him an elite prospect.

13.  Wil Myers, OF, Kansas City: 12/10/90, Double-A

.254/.353/.393, 23 2B, 8 HR, 87/52 K/BB, 9 SB

Myers moved to RF from catcher last season so that he could move quicker through the system.  He didn’t post the numbers that he did in 2010, but he was slowed by various injuries in 2011 and was just 20 in Double-A.  He could repeat in Double-A in 2012 due to his struggles, but he won’t be there long when he returns to 2010 form.  That’s right…when.  He is a future star on the same side of the field as the Royals foundation, Eric Hosmer.

14.  Carlos Martinez, RHP, St. Louis: 9/21/91, High-A

6-5, 3.93 ERA, 84 2/3 IP, 98/44 K/BB, .238 BAA

Martinez possesses upside that could make him better than future teammate Shelby Miller.  He needs to get more innings under his belt in 2012 to see what the Cardinals have.  If he does what he’s done the last couple of seasons, he’ll be a top five prospect in 2013.

15.  Jameson Taillon, RHP, Pittsburgh: 11/18/91, Low-A

2-3, 3.98 ERA, 92 2/3 IP, 97/22 K/BB, .249 BAA

Taillon was babied by the Pirates in 2011, as the Bucs didn’t allow Taillon to go more than 5 innings in any start.  That is understandable: see Bobby Bradley and John Van Benschoten.  Taillon and Cole could be a solid 1-2 for Pittsburgh for years to come, but it wouldn’t surprise me if Taillon is the #1.

16.  Danny Hultzen, LHP, Seattle: 11/28/89, NONE; Played in Arizona Fall League

1-0, 1.40 ERA, 19 1/3 IP, 18/5 K/BB, .225 BAA

Hultzen has a mid-90’s fastball and is about as polished of a college arm that you will ever see.  He has huge fantasy upside due to pitching in Safeco, but he would have that wherever he would have landed.  He could start 2012 in Double-A, but if he doesn’t, he’ll get there quickly.

17.  Taijuan Walker, RHP, Seattle: 8/13/92, Low-A

6-5, 2.89 ERA, 96 2/3 IP, 113/39 K/BB, .202 BAA

Walker is a future ace.  He is a big kid who could fill out and become even more intriguing than he already is, which is scary.  It’ll be interesting to see what Seattle does with him, as Inland Empire of the California League could lead to a short stay and a jump to Double-A, saving Walker from confidence issues.

18.  Gerrit Cole, RHP, Pittsburgh: 9/8/90, NONE; Played in Arizona Fall League

2-0, 3.00 ERA, 15 IP, 16/4 K/BB, .179 BAA

Cole was the #1 pick in the 2011 MLB Draft and he has “upside” out the wazoo.  Like I mentioned earlier, his college teammate, Trevor Bauer, seemed to out-pitch him in 2011, but Cole has the 100+ mph fastball that makes people envious.  He looked very good in the AFL, so I, like others, am looking forward to where Pittsburgh starts him and how he does.

19.  Nolan Arenado, 3B, Colorado: 4/16/91, High-A

.298/.349/.487, 32 2B, 20 HR, 122 RBI, 53/47 K/BB

I love this guy, maybe a bit too much.  Maybe it’s the fact that there aren’t many good third basemen in baseball right now, maybe I like when 20 year-olds post solid power numbers.  Sure, it was in the California League, but Arenado shows the ability to make contact, just 53 strikeouts in 517 at bats, and it isn’t like the Rockies ballpark isn’t a hitter’s paradise, either.  Huge upside here.

20.  Travis d’Arnaud, C, Toronto: 2/10/89, Double-A

.311/.371/.542, 33 2B, 21 HR, 100/33 K/BB

Just like Mesoraco did in 2010, d’Arnaud finally had his breakout in 2011 in Double-A, showing incredible power while developing a major issue in Toronto.  With J.P. Arencibia already in Toronto, what will the Jays do with these two power hitting monsters behind the plate?  I am wondering if the club might look to get d’Arnaud some looks at first or left field in Triple-A in 2012.  They may not want to mess with what they have, but it wouldn’t hurt their future lineup if they can keep d’Arnaud’s bat in it.

21.  Manny Banuelos, LHP, Yankees: 3/13/91, Triple-A

6-7, 3.75 ERA, 129 2/3 IP, 125/71 K/BB, .266 BAA

22.  Gary Brown, OF, San Francisco: 9/28/88, High-A

.336/.407/.519, 34 2B, 13 3B, 14 HR, 80 RBI, 77/46 K/BB, 53 SB

23.  Tyler Skaggs, LHP, Arizona: 7/13/91, Double-A

9-6, 2.96 ERA, 158 1/3 IP, 198/49 K/BB, .218 BAA

24.  Jarrod Parker, RHP, Oakland: 11/24/88, Majors

11-8, 3.79 ERA, 130 2/3 IP, 112/55 K/BB, .236 BAA

25.  Jonathan Singleton, 1B, Houston: 9/18/91, High-A

.298/.392/.441, 23 2B, 13 HR, 123/70 K/BB

26.  Michael Choice, OF, Oakland: 11/10/89, High-A

.285/.376/.542, 28 2B, 30 HR, 134/61 K/BB, 9 SB

27.  Miguel Sano, 3B, Minnesota: 5/11/93, Rookie Ball

.292/.352/.637, 18 2B, 7 3B, 20 HR, 59 RBI, 77/23 K/BB, 5 SB…267 AB

28.  Eddie Rosario, OF, Minnesota: 9/28/91, Rookie Ball

.337/.397/.670, 9 2B, 9 3B, 21 HR, 60 RBI, 60/27 K/BB, 17 SB…270 AB

29.  Hak-Ju Lee, SS, Tampa Bay: 11/4/90, Double-A

.292/.365/.416, 17 2B, 15 3B, 5 HR, 94/53 K/BB, 33 SB

30.  Zack Wheeler, RHP, Mets: 5/30/90, High-A

9-7, 3.52 ERA, 115 IP, 129/52 K/BB, .231 BAA

31.  Christian Yelich, 1B/OF, Miami: 12/5/91, Low-A

.312/.388/.484, 32 2B, 15 HR, 77 RBI, 102/55 K/BB, 32 SB

32.  Oscar Taveras, OF, St. Louis: 6/19/92, Low-A

.386/.444/.584, 27 2B, 5 3B, 8 HR, 62 RBI, 52/32 K/BB…308 AB

33.  Oswaldo Arcia, OF, Minnesota: 5/9/91, High-A

.291/.335/.531, 23 2B, 4 3B, 13 HR, 51 RBI, 70/18 K/BB

34.  Zack Cox, 3B, St. Louis: 5/9/89, Double-A

.306/.363/.434, 27 2B, 13 HR, 68 RBI, 98/40 K/BB

35.  Jean Segura, 2B/SS, Angels: 3/17/90, High-A

.281/.337/.422, 9 2B, 4 3B, 3 HR, 26/15 K/BB, 18 SB…185 AB

36.  Yonder Alonso, 1B, San Diego: 4/8/87, Majors

.296/.374/.486, 24 2B, 4 3B, 12 HR, 60/46 K/BB, 6 SB

37.  Anthony Rizzo, 1B, Cubs: 8/8/89, Majors

.331/.404/.652, 34 2B, 26 HR, 101 RBI, 89/43 K/BB in 356 AB

38.  Brad Peacock, RHP, Oakland: 2/2/88, Majors

15-3, 2.39 ERA, 146 2/3 IP, 177/47 K/BB, .188 BAA

39.  James Paxton, LHP, Seattle: 11/6/88, Double-A

6-3, 2.37 ERA, 95 IP, 131/43 K/BB, .215 BAA

40.  Drew Pomeranz, LHP, Colorado: 11/22/88, Majors

4-3, 1.78 ERA, 101 IP, 119/38 K/BB, .189 BAA

41.  Yasmani Grandal, C, San Diego: 11/8/88, Triple-A

.305/.401/.500, 31 2B, 14 HR, 68 RBI, 97/59 K/BB

42.  Trevor May, RHP, Philadelphia: 9/23/89, High-A

10-8, 3.63 ERA, 151 1/3 IP, 208/67 K/BB, .221 BAA

43.  Bubba Starling, OF, Kansas City: 8/3/92, NONE

44.  Dylan Bundy, RHP, Baltimore: 11/15/92, NONE

45.  Jonathan Schoop, 2B/3B, Baltimore: 10/16/91, High-A

.290/.349/.432, 24 2B, 5 3B, 13 HR, 71 RBI, 76/42 K/BB, 12 SB

46.  Rymer Liriano, OF, San Diego: 6/20/91, High-A

.298/.365/.465, 31 2B, 9 3B, 12 HR, 68 RBI, 108/53 K/BB, 66 SB

47.  Jake Marisnick, OF, Toronto: 3/30/91, Low-A

.320/.392/.496, 27 2B, 6 3B, 14 HR, 77 RBI, 91/43 K/BB, 37 SB

48.  Mike Montgomery, LHP, Kansas City: 7/1/89, Triple-A

5-11, 5.32 ERA, 150 2/3 IP, 129/69 K/BB, .271 BAA

49.  Jake Odorizzi, RHP, Kansas City: 3/27/90, Double-A

10-7, 3.73 ERA, 147 IP, 157/44 K/BB, .244 BAA

50.  Anthony Gose, OF, Toronto: 8/10/90, Double-A

.253/.349/.415, 20 2B, 7 3B, 16 HR, 154/62 K/BB, 70 SB


9 thoughts on “2012 Top 50 Prospects

    1. He’s borderline as a prospect/rookie label since he had so much time in the Majors in 2011. I know he’ll still have rookie status and he is still a top prospect if you consider that he is within that label. He’d be #2 on the list if he “qualified” as a prospect still, in my opinion. That would have been a hellacious oversight if I didn’t consider him at all, so thanks for pointing that out, as I didn’t mention the reason why I didn’t put him on here as I put the list together.


  1. Ok – I’d like to incorporate your list at http://www.fantasyleaguegm.com/category/consensus-mlb-prospect-rankings-2012/

    I’m handy with excel, so I can slot Trout as 2 and bump everyone down 1 spot on my table. Did you ever do a 51-100 list?

    Oh, we’ve been trying to find partners: http://fantasyleaguegm.com is looking to merge – writers would run/edit/control their own material under shared domain name.

    hit me up if you’re interested (email submitted)


    1. You can run the list, that is fine. Right now, I’m going to maintain my site. I’m starting Grad school and I don’t want to commit to anything right now on a merger. I’m also holding out hope that ESPN offers me a 6-figure deal to move there!


    1. There aren’t many guys who go 10-10 with a 4.12 ERA and a 101/56 K/BB in 144 1/3 IP that go on to be superstars. He throws hard but he doesn’t throw enough strikes or miss enough bats. With that being said, he’ll be 22 in May and has time to make adjustments. Crazier things have happened, but Singleton was the only “STAR” the Astros got back in the Pence deal. Cosart could be a solid #4 starter if things keep up the way they have, but he isn’t the top-of-the-rotation arm that many thought they were getting in the trade.


What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s